Contents
1. No Company Can Guarantee Google Rankings
If I had to sum up the problem in one sentence, it would be:
You can’t guarantee what you don’t fully control.
With paid ads (e.g., Google Ads), it’s straightforward—raising your budget can boost your ad’s position. But SEO works entirely differently. Organic rankings depend on search engine algorithms that are constantly changing. No agency controls those algorithms, and Google itself warns against promises of quick, “guaranteed” top spots.
If someone promises you a specific ranking within 30 days, they’re either overestimating their abilities or, in the worst case, knowingly misleading you.
2. Lightning-Fast Results Often Mean Risky Techniques
SEO is a marathon, not a sprint. Achieving stable results typically takes months or even years.
Yet many “guaranteed” SEO services rely on black hat SEO techniques—like mass-buying unnatural links or copying large amounts of content. These methods might temporarily propel your site to the top, but they usually end in penalties from Google. When that happens, your site can vanish from the rankings entirely, and you’re left without organic traffic and with the hassle of cleaning up the mess.
Let’s compare two hypothetical situations:
- Scenario A (no “SEO guarantee”):
You pay for SEO, but the first few months yield minimal results. Around the sixth month, you start to see a return on your investment, and by the twelfth month, traffic and sales from Google are on solid footing. - Scenario B (with a “guarantee,” e.g., “Top 10 in 30 days”):
You actually reach the Top 10 in 30 days, but it turns out they used methods that violate Google’s guidelines. After a while, your site is penalized and loses all its traffic. You end up with nothing—often worse off, because you may need to start over with a new domain if the old one is “burned.”
It’s pretty clear which scenario is riskier.
3. Guaranteed Rankings Usually Don’t Translate into Profit
Even if someone manages to quickly rank your site for a few keywords, it doesn’t mean it will boost your sales. Often, these “guaranteed” keywords:
- Have tiny search volume (nobody is really looking for them).
- Don’t relate directly to your business niche.
- Are easy to rank for but don’t drive conversions (for example, informational rather than transactional queries).
As a result, you might get what was promised—better rankings on paper—but it won’t affect your sales or the number of customers you acquire.
4. A Short-Term Win Doesn’t Ensure Long-Term Success
Signing a year-long contract that promises results in 30 days might sound fantastic, but if the agency fulfills the promise (even briefly), you might not get anything else from them for the remaining months.
In extreme cases, agencies use quick, aggressive tactics to meet minimal guarantee requirements, then do nothing further. If the site gets penalized a month or two later, they’ve already “met” the guarantee, so you won’t get your money back or additional help.
A perfect example is conch-house.com, which skyrocketed to over six million monthly visitors in just two months, earning about $20,000 a day. However, it relied on spammy methods—publishing thousands of copied posts daily—and was banned by Google in its third month.
From the perspective of many “guarantees,” the goal was achieved: the site exploded in rankings in record time. But once Google stepped in, it all fell apart, leaving the owners with nothing.
What Does the Only Sensible “SEO Guarantee” Look Like?
There is a type of SEO guarantee considered both ethical and safe. Below is an example from an actual law firm (Legal Eagles) that helped draft a clause like this for a service provider:
|
|
What Makes This Type of Guarantee Stand Out?
- The service provider is responsible for relevant, meaningful results—things that truly impact your business (traffic, conversions, revenue).
- It accounts for long-term performance, not just a short-term spike.
- It doesn’t promise specific Google rankings but focuses on achieving growth aligned with the client’s interests.
- It’s clear and transparent, with a well-defined scope and exclusions.
- It avoids “legal loopholes” by not relying on random, zero-search-volume keywords.
- It was prepared by a lawyer who understands SEO, so it’s solid from a legal standpoint.
The best part is there’s no assumption of magic control over Google’s algorithm. It simply acknowledges that a properly executed SEO strategy should eventually deliver real growth. If it doesn’t, the agency must keep working on their own dime.
How to Choose a Trustworthy SEO Agency
1. Does the Agency Focus on Growing Your Business?
A good agency starts by understanding your goals—whether that’s more sales, more leads, more bookings, etc.—and then sets success metrics. These might include:
- Number of conversions
- Revenue growth
- Increased profit margin
- Campaign ROI
Rankings or Google traffic alone are just a means to an end. If the agency doesn’t ask about your business goals but instead talks only about “increasing your traffic by 200%,” there’s a risk they won’t focus on actual profits.
2. Look for Proof of Long-Term Results
Instead of seeking a “guarantee,” check portfolios or case studies. If an agency can showcase multiple projects running for 12–24 months (or longer), demonstrating clear growth in conversions or revenue, that’s a good sign they know what they’re doing.
Pay attention to details like:
- How many projects succeeded (not just one or two examples)?
- Do they show long-term improvements (rather than brief spikes)?
- Do they mention ROI or revenue growth, not just clicks?
- Which services were provided (content creation, link building, technical SEO fixes)?
You can also verify data using public tools like Semrush:
- Changes in organic traffic
- Traffic value
- Link profile
- Keyword range (is it really growing?)
3. Transparency and White Hat SEO Methods
Ask openly about the agency’s approach. If you hear vague promises like “1,000 links in a week” or “we own a network of blogs,” that’s a red flag pointing to black hat methods.
Look instead for a partner who emphasizes quality content, responsible link-building, and technical optimization of your website. Honest agencies clearly outline their monthly tasks, expected results, and timelines.
4. Regular Reporting and Ongoing Progress Updates
A reliable provider doesn’t dodge accountability; they’ll offer monthly or quarterly reports highlighting key metrics—the ones that genuinely impact your business (e.g., increased revenue from organic search or the number of new leads).
Of course, if you want them to track something like the exact value of sales from Google, you’ll need to share that data (from your e-commerce platform, CRM, etc.). If you don’t, they can only report on SEO metrics like organic traffic and its estimated value.
Conclusion
Most “SEO guarantees” are, at best, an agency’s overconfidence or, at worst, an attempt to lure you in with quick but often unethical tactics. Such shortcuts might yield short-term success but can lead to penalties from Google and, in some cases, force you to start over from scratch.
However, there is an ethical guarantee based on long-term, genuine results—if the agency doesn’t achieve growth in conversions or revenue, they commit to working for free until they do. This approach focuses on what your business actually needs, doesn’t try to fool search algorithms, and goes beyond empty metrics like “rank” or “traffic.”
If you have any questions about SEO guarantees or want to avoid the usual pitfalls, feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn. Good luck securing top positions on Google—without risky shortcuts!